2022 WMU Graphic Design Thesis Projects's profile

Plant to Paper: Invasive Species Papermaking Program

Thesis Statement: 
In Southwest Michigan there are several invasive plant varieties that are damaging ecosystems and harming native flora. This program, Plant to Paper, will facilitate the identification and removal of harmful invasive species around Kalamazoo County.
Program Deliverables: ​​​​​​​​​​​​​​
Promotional posters and social media posts, promotional lawn flags, mobile website, informational booklet, and papermaking troubleshooting handout.
Presentation:
Project Narrative:

Background Information
Plant to Paper is a multi-day, educational, hands-on program where participants will learn about local invasive plants and how to turn them into a usable paper product. On the first day, participants will learn how to identify and harvest the unwanted plants and go out in the world to find said plants. The second day of the program is dedicated to processing the harvested plant fibers for papermaking. The last day, participants will create a finished paper product with the same plant material that they harvested on the first day. 

Any kind of living organism that is not native to the ecosystem it resides in and causes harm to can be considered an invasive species. The harm caused by an invasive species is not limited to the natural ecosystem, it also includes harm to the environment, the economy, or even human health. Species that grow and reproduce quickly, and spread aggressively, with potential to cause harm, are labelled as “invasive.” The direct threats of invasive species include: preying on native species, outcompeting native species for food or other resources, causing or carrying disease, and preventing native species from reproducing or killing a native species’ young.

On a more local level, southwest Michigan is home to a plethora of invasive species, both flora and fauna. This program, Plant to Paper, addresses and educates the issue of invasive flora in the Kalamazoo area and contributes to management efforts to reduce the spread of these unwanted plants.

Audience
The audience for Plant to Paper is anyone with the attention span to complete all the steps of the papermaking process. Students, faculty, and staff at Western Michigan University, people of all ages in the Kalamazoo area with an interest in sustainable practices, papermaking, as well as nature conservation are included in the intended audience for the program.

Goals
By participating in the program, I want the audience to understand a potential use of local invasive species instead of simply throwing them away once dug up. Plant to Paper will explore and educate about an alternative, beyond going digital, to reduce conventional paper waste. Additionally, I want the audience to learn the fun and accessible craft of papermaking first-hand.

Research Process
The research for this project began with exercises done in class: word association and mind mapping. After these exercises I gathered both visual and informational resources to reference for the project. Once I had my initial research sources, I began the design process which then eventually led to more research, especially on the specific plants mentioned in the handout booklet.
Research:

Design
I referenced several books and videos about tips for designing identities. I also had a consultation with professional designer Kristy Campbell. She walked me through her process for rebrands and gave me advice for creating the deliverables for the project.

Plants
I utilized an official list of invasive species provided by the state of Michigan as the foundation of my research on the subject. I also referenced an array of articles that went into specifics about how to most effectively manage stands of the invasive plants.

Papermaking
I interned at the Kalamazoo Book Arts Center during the spring 2022 semester where I was able to learn how to make paper by hand and consult with the studio manager of the Book Arts Center: Katie Platte. I also had a consultation with artist and papermaker Megan Heeres about her process and tips for conducting papermaking workshops for beginners.
Design Process: 

Visual Inspiration Research​​​​​​​
• Balkis chair — Found on Instagram, the organic material and form of the chair were inspirations for the hand-made elements I used throughout the program deliverables.

• Khounnoraj scarf — Found on Instagram, the imperfect circles and multiple textures were also inspirations for the hand-made elements used throughout the program deliverables.

• Studio Noon chair — Found on Instagram, the roundness and visual softness of the piece contributed to the welcoming feeling I wanted the program's identity to have.

• Zamaraeva ceramic teeth — Found on Instagram, the ceramic teeth all generally have the same form yet have different colors to make each one stand out, this contributed to how I arranged the information for each plant: including the same information but having illustrations and assigned colors for each to make them more distinguishable.

• Zamaraeva ceramic slugs — Found on Instagram, the arrangement of the ceramic slugs to create an organic pattern influenced early design element choices that I later decided to not include in the final versions.

• Lee vessel — Found on Instagram, the transitioning wavy lines around the vessel contributed to the movement I wanted to convey in the identity of the program.

• Watson architecture — Found on Instagram, the architecture being simple in color yet clean and complex in form inspired the way I went about including embellishing and emphasizing elements on the posters and handouts.

• WMU OfS poster — Seen around WMU's campus, I wanted to have a reference of what visuals the Office for Sustainability already used on promotional materials.

• Matter of Trust social media posts — Found on Instagram, the simple illustrations and colors used inspired the idea for including illustrations throughout the program's deliverables.
Identity Development​​​​​​​
Initial sketches for the identity ranged from chunky to intricate letterforms. First refinements simplified the letterforms and focused more on the interaction of the letters between the words. Further refinements experimented with paper shapes to tie in with the name of the program, also playing with movement and tying the words together. Next sketches moved away from the paper shapes and instead refocused on the interaction of the letters between the words. After narrowing down to two possible directions for the identity, ultimately I went with the direction without the paper shape. The final identity shown in color ties in with the movement and transformation that the program revolves around. 
Illustration Process​​​​​​​
The illustration process began with simple black line work. After dropping some illustrations into the handout booklet, I realized that the black was too harsh and felt sterile instead of natural and inviting. I then tried adding color to just the line work, which did not achieve the look I wanted. I went back and refined the sketches, creating more nuance. Then, I added more realistic fill colors instead of coloring the line work which became the final process for all of the illustrations featured throughout the program's deliverables.
Promotional Poster Process​​​​​​​
The initial poster designs were constrained within the classic portrait poster layout. After multiple rounds of refinements for the content of the posters, it was suggested to me to try out a format where posters would tile together instead of a single one standing alone. I reconfigured the content across multiple posters and eventually landed on the final design of two main posters that connect edge to edge with accompanying satellite posters that can be rearranged to fit around existing posters on campus.
Public Interactive Process​​​​​​​
I originally envisioned the public interactive flags to be the same size and material as the existing construction lawn flags. My preliminary designs were made to fit on the small, square flags, but after some critiques and refinements I realized that my flags needed to be more attention-grabbing. The new flags were larger and bright scarlet to stand out against the green foliage of the environment they would be placed in, but still not quite right. After more critiques and suggestions, I tried out a frame layout for the flags to more accurately point out the problem plant. The first mockup was too flimsy, but the final version is much more sturdy due to being printed on water resistant paper and mounted on foam core to add strength and withstand its outdoor environment.
Mobile Website Design
The mobile website for Plant to Paper can be reached by scanning the QR code found on promotional posters and public interactive flags. The landing page of the website features the identity and prompts the viewer to scroll down to identify one of the plants they may have come across either by small satellite poster or in the real world through a lawn flag. After choosing a plant, the website provides information about why the plant is an issue and suggests learning more about the program on the "About" page of the site. A sign up function is included on the "Get Involved" page for those who are interested in participating after learning about one or more of the local invasive plants and the program.
Informational Booklet Process​​​​​​​
The process for the informational booklet handout was the most in-depth. Not only did the book require the most research for the content within, it also had the most intricate layout designs and physical construction. I created spreads for each plant noted in the book that address the habitats the plants are found in, how to identify each plant and distinguish the invasive varieties from non-invasive lookalikes, and also how to properly harvest each plant to avoid regrowth. Included in the spreads are photographs of the plants and their non-invasive lookalikes, along with my illustrations to highlight specific attributes of the plants to aid in identification. After the layout was completed, I needed to construct the books. I made my own paper (with cotton fiber instead of invasive plant material due to the time of the year) and had the program identity laser cut into plywood which was used to emboss the booklets' covers. Finally, I bound the book together using the coptic stitch to allow for maximum flexibility when opened and laid out on the ground when participants are harvesting their plants.
Reflection:

The outcome of the Plant to Paper program was quite successful in my opinion. Research for the project taught me a lot about the process and the plants, but also about how I manage myself throughout a large, ongoing project. As for the process, I learned that I prefer layout design over identity design and that overall, I enjoy the physical processes of the project over the strictly digital ones. Expanding on this project, I would like to further refine the mobile website and include more plants in the booklet. Throughout this project I noticed that I used the same approach for almost each deliverable and how it caused a lot of creativity issues for me. For the future I'm going to work on keeping more of an open mind and experiment more with my designs.
Sources:
• Airey, D. (2019). Identity designed: the definitive guide to visual branding. Rockport Publishers.
• Babcock, M. (n.d.). Make a Mould and Deckle for Handmade Paper – Cheap, Quick & Dirty. Paperslurry. https://www.paperslurry.com/2014/08/01/make-mould/
• Bell, L. (1986). Plant Fibers for Papermaking. Liliaceae Press.
• Bowers, M. (n.d.). Brand Illustration 101: Visualizing the Narrative. Designers. https://www.toptal.com/designers/brand/brand-illustration-system
• Brandfolder. (2019, December 3). How to Differentiate Your Brand in a Crowded Market. Brand New. https://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/archives/how_to_differentiate_your_brand_in_a_crowded_market.php
• Branstrom, I., Jubenville, J. (2021). Drive-by botany: Purple loosestrife and spotted knapweed. Michigan State University Extension. https://www.canr.msu.edu/news/drive-by-botany-purple-loosestrife-and-spotted-knapweed#:~:text=Common%20look%2Dalikes%3A%20Marsh%20blazing,%2C%20fireweed%20(Chamaenerion%20angustifolium).
• Butler Branding Agency. (2018, August 24). HOW TO: Design a Brand Identity System [Video file]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XUi8Ftxq9jo
• Connick, A. [Abi Connick]. (2021, September 12). Designing a Jewellery Brand from scratch [Video file]. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=UmJiwtGUgxs.
• Devon Wildlife Trust. (2019). Invasive Himalayan Balsam Removal Volunteer Opportunity. Devon Wildlife Trust. https://www.devonwildlifetrust.org/sites/default/files/2019-08/Himalayan%20Balsam%20Opportunity%20Poster%20Aug%202019.pdf
• DiTomaso, J. M. (2013). Spotted Knapweed. Weed Control in Natural Areas in the Western United States. https://wric.ucdavis.edu/information/natural%20areas/wr_C/Centaurea_stoebe.pdf
• East Multnomah Soil and Water Conservation District. (2016). Getting rid of invasive garlic mustard!. East Multnomah Soil and Water Conservation District. https://emswcd.org/removing-garlic-mustard/
• East Multnomah Soil and Water Conservation District. (n.d.). Garlic Mustard. East Multnomah Soil and Water Conservation District. https://emswcd.org/on-your-land/weeds/weeds-to-know/garlic-mustard/
• Hiebert, H. (1998). Papermaking with Plants: Creative Recipes and Projects Using Herbs, Flowers, Grasses, and Leaves. Storey Books.
• Johnson, M. (2016). Branding: In Five and a Half Steps. Thames & Hudson.
• Imagination. (n.d.). Designing a hybrid learning experience for the next generation of creatives Saturday Club. Imagination. https://imagination.com/work/the-saturday-club-a-hybrid-learning-experience
• Khounnoraj, A. [@bookhou]. (2021, October 5). I made Piper a scarf with the pinch whip stitch pattern. The material is an indigo dyed wool fabric which. [Photograph]. Instagram. https://www.instagram.com/p/CUpmBqarQUL/?utm_medium=share_sheet
• Lee, J. [@jaiiklee]. (2021, September 14). [Crescent moon emoji]. [Photograph]. Instagram. https://www.instagram.com/p/CTyuyiGBrFz/?utm_medium=share_sheet
• Michigan Department of Natural Resources Michigan Natural Features Inventory. (2012). Black and Pale Swallow-worts. Michigan Department of Natural Resources Michigan Natural Features Inventory. https://mnfi.anr.msu.edu/invasive-species/Swallow-wortBCP.pdf
• Michigan.gov. (n.d.). Invasive Plants. Michigan.gov. https://www.michigan.gov/invasives/id-report/plants 
• New York Invasive Species (IS) Information. (2019). Swallow-wort, Pale and Black. New York Invasive Species (IS) Information. http://nyis.info/invasive_species/swallow-wort/#:~:text=Chemical%20Control%3A,2005).
• Pentagram. (n.d.). Battersea. Pentagram. https://www.pentagram.com/work/battersea
• Pentagram. (2021). 2021 Film Independent Spirit Awards. Pentagram. https://www.pentagram.com/work/2021-film-independent-spirit-awards?rel=discipline&rel-id=1
• Pink Pony Creative. (n.d.). Mako Pizza Co. www.pinkponycreative.com. https://www.pinkponycreative.com/mako
• Pink Pony Creative. (n.d.). Tamara Meyer. www.pinkponycreative.com. https://www.pinkponycreative.com/tamara-meyer
• Rook/NYC. (2022, January 21). New Packaging for Alicia’s Spice Co. by Rook/NYC. Brand New. https://www.underconsideration.com/brandnew/archives/new_packaging_for_alicias_spice_co__by_rook_nyc.php
• Southeast Exotic Pest Plant Council. (n.d.). Southeast Exotic Pest Plant Council Invasive Plant Manual. Southeast Exotic Pest Plant Council. https://www.se-eppc.org/manual/DIOP.html#:~:text=Using%20a%20pulaski%20or%20similar,not%20removed%20will%20potentially%20resprout.
• The National Wildlife Federation. (n.d.)."Invasive species"—they may not sound very threatening, but these invaders, large and small, have devastating effects on wildlife. The National Wildlife Federation. https://www.nwf.org/Educational-Resources/Wildlife-Guide/Threats-to-Wildlife/Invasive-Species#:~:text=An%20invasive%20species%20can%20be,economy%2C%20or%20even%20human%20health.
• TraceLoops. [@traceloops]. (2021, June 7). 06-07-2021_overlapPhena. High res scans, music downloads and more on patreon. [Video]. Instagram. https://www.instagram.com/p/CP1YCSsBzU_/?utm_medium=share_sheet
• University of Minnesota Extension. (2019). Report and remove black swallow-wort plant to help monarch butterflies. University of Minnesota Extension. https://extension.umn.edu/news/report-and-remove-black-swallow-wort-plant-help-monarch-butterflies
• Wheeler, A. (2012). Designing Brand Identity: An Essential Guide for the Whole Branding Team. John Wiley & Sons, Incorporated.
• White, C. (2022). The Best Way to Get Rid of Garlic Mustard, an Invasive Weed. Dengarden.
 https://dengarden.com/gardening/The-Best-Way-to-Get-Rid-of-Garlic-Mustard-an-Invasive-Weed
• Wise Knotweed Solutions. (n.d.). Himalayan Balsam. Wise Knotweed Solutions. https://www.wiseknotweed.com/services/himalayan-balsam/
• Zamaraeva, A. [@a_zama_ceramics]. (2021, January 9). I'm starting to send out the slug pre-orders from Monday. Theres still more I need to make but I have. [Photograph]. Instagram. https://www.instagram.com/p/CJ1TdOIjUzb/?utm_medium=share_sheet

Plant to Paper: Invasive Species Papermaking Program
Published:

Plant to Paper: Invasive Species Papermaking Program

Published: